Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

    I thought Atkins would solve all my weight, hunger and craving problems.

    I was really excited about it and thought it would be very easy to me. Plus in theory, the science behind it sounds very correct.

    I only lasted a few days on induction twice, and i'm not even sure if I reached ketosis. I did get blinding migraines a few days into it though.

    But I kept having to scrutinize ingredients in everything, and I didn't realize that so many things have traces of sugar in them (mayo, sausages, cream cheese, etc). I don't want to keep throwing things out because of that.

    Plus I thought eating the amount of meat and eggs and butter and olive oil that I was eating would keep me full, but I still found I was hungry.

    Also, I found it quite difficult to make meat flavorful without the use of bbq sauces. My city does not have any place to buy sugar-free sauces, and anything that is sugar-free has aspartame in it. So that makes it quite hard.

    I also was constantly wondering whether or not I was keeping myself at 20 grams of carbs daily. I kept thinking "If I add these two lettuce leaves and this one tbsp of cream will I be over 20 grams?" "If I put 2 packets of Splenda in my decaf tea will I still be able to have that chunk of green pepper in my salad?"

    Finally, I have to face this. My heritige is of the East Coast Canadian sort. We are a people who make fish hash with white potatoes and who ate slices of fresh homemade bread wth butter and molasses on the way to school and who enjoy carrots and peas with our Turkey at Christmas and who's mothers made prize-winning pies and brownies. When I was growing up I ate these things and I never ever developed a weight problem until I went away to college and became addicted to fast food and became sedentry.

    So maybe the thing for me to do is just try and get as much exercise as I can, stop with the fast food, and cut down on the really bad carbs.

    Kudos to everyone on here who has had success with Atkins, but perhaps you are all made of stronger stuff than I.

    Good luck to all that are sticking with it, but I'm going to bow out.

    Ultrachic, Atkins failure.

  • #2
    Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

    Originally posted by ultrachic View Post
    I only lasted a few days on induction twice, and i'm not even sure if I reached ketosis. I did get blinding migraines a few days into it though.
    For headaches, you can take an OTC painkiller.

    But I kept having to scrutinize ingredients in everything, and I didn't realize that so many things have traces of sugar in them (mayo, sausages, cream cheese, etc). I don't want to keep throwing things out because of that.
    You don't have to throw things out. Read the ingredients in the foods you buy BEFORE you buy them.

    Full-fat commercial mayonnaise typically has a small amount of sugar added to it. For most people, it does not interfere with weight loss.

    Sausages are processed meat and often have a form of sugar added. Some people occasionally have sausages without problems. It's an individual thing and you'll need to see if they work for you. Making them a daily item on your menu is probably not be the best idea though.

    Cream cheese should not have sugar added to it. Does sugar appear in the list of ingredients? If it does, then change the brand. Cream cheese has carbohydrates, but they come from the lactose naturally occurring in milk.

    Plus I thought eating the amount of meat and eggs and butter and olive oil that I was eating would keep me full, but I still found I was hungry.
    How much were you actually eating? Do you want to post a menu, with quantities and net carbs?

    Also, I found it quite difficult to make meat flavorful without the use of bbq sauces.
    You can make sugar free BBQ sauce:

    Sugar-Free BBQ Sauce - Low-Carb Barbeque Sauce Recipe

    You can make ketchup, too:

    Linda's Low Carb Menus & Recipes

    There are more ideas for sauces on Linda's page:

    Linda's Low Carb Menus & Recipes - Misc. Recipes

    I also was constantly wondering whether or not I was keeping myself at 20 grams of carbs daily.
    First of all, those should be 20 net carbs, not 20 carbs.

    Second, are you using FitDay to track your foods? FitDay will tell you if eating <insert food> will put you over 20 net carbs. Planning your menus a few days in advance helps, too.

    Finally, I have to face this. My heritige is of the East Coast Canadian sort. We are a people who make fish hash with white potatoes and who ate slices of fresh homemade bread wth butter and molasses on the way to school and who enjoy carrots and peas with our Turkey at Christmas and who's mothers made prize-winning pies and brownies.
    This is what many people ate pre-Atkins, don't you think? Apart from the weight issues, do you think it's healthy?

    And you can have potatoes, bread, carrots and peas in OWL. You can make low carb pies and brownies.

    You can also learn to like new foods. That's what changing your way of eating assumes.

    So maybe the thing for me to do is just try and get as much exercise as I can, stop with the fast food, and cut down on the really bad carbs.
    Which are, in your opinion, the "really bad carbs"?

    Maybe you can have the others on Atkins, too, or maybe we can suggest some substitutes for them.
    "Get action. Seize the moment. Man was never intended to become an oyster."

    -- Theodore Roosevelt

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

      While I do believe that Atkins is right for me, I know it isn't a good fit for everyone. For some folks, Weight Watchers works. For others just cutting quantities. I hope you find the formula that works for you. Wishing you best of luck with your choice and hoping you achieve your goals no matter how you choose to get there.
      JILL

      HW 298
      HW (this time) 248
      GOAL ONE 228
      (take 2)
      GOAL TWO 213 (personal goal)
      GOAL THREE 199 ONE-DERLAND
      FINAL GOAL 165

      It's not about the results. Its about the process.

      "I've never come home after a workout and said, MAN, I wish I had NOT exercised today!"



      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

        One thing that may help you ( it certainly has helped me ) is to use a free program on the web called "Fitday" . It allows you to build up a list of your favorite foods , so you know whether you are keeping to your carb limit .

        I tried Atkins last year , but I didn't use fit day and gave up after a few months with limited sucess .

        This time , I am doing much better and I keep control with Fitday .

        Why not give it a try before throwing in the towel

        good luck ,

        Blubberman

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

          You definitely need a tool to get you going like Fitday. It gives you a sense of what you are eating the first few weeks. It's a good idea to keep using it throughout but it helps you gain confidence when shopping and eating out as you know how common foods break down.

          Also, I believe many cultures have some sort of traditional starch component. I'm a black girl with Carolina coastal roots. Our entire diet is anchored by some sort of carb whether it be grits or rice. Biscuits or potatoes. Once you break those addictions, they are not issues. You really have to make it through those first few days but it really does not happen. Trust me. I used to buy rice in restaurant quantities for my household. Don't even touch it now. It really can work.

          Best of luck to you on your journey though...
          SW:301/CW:277/GW:170
          Mini goal 1: 275
          Mini goal 2: 250
          Mini goal 3: 225
          Goal.....

          Female
          Mini goal ticker



          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

            You're not a failure.
            Sometimes we are not ready for something. Or it is not for us.
            Wish you lots of luck in Halifax. Watching curling from there right now
            Startdate: November 18, 2007. Female 5'2"

            May Challenges 2010
            Push-ups: 450/800
            Abs: 850/1900
            Squats: 650/1200
            Lunges: 500/1000
            Strength: 490/1200
            Running: 50/100 km


            2 Years on Atkins.................. President Challenge Medals earned

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

              Hi,
              If you feel Atkins is not the way for you, that's your choice, and I hope you find a weight loss plan that you are comfortable with if you do not continue with the Atkins WOL.

              But I just have 2 comments to add. (LONG Comments...)

              1- I am a big "NO EXCUSE" person. Just about Everyone comes from some cultural background that revolves around food. And in most cases it is high carb, lots of this and that, whatever, all of our families LOVE to indulge in every high carb, high sugar, high everything at every possible holiday and family event. My background is Eastern European-dumplings of all shapes and sizes and fattening desserts--my spouse, his food, you have to eat a tons of rice with each dinner or there is something considered wrong with you. So that is just an excuse, if you want to change the way you eat, do it, but don't blame a cultural eating as a reason you may not be able to.

              I bring an Atkins friendly dish, appetizer, or dessert, or all of the above to every family gathering, even like today, just getting together with Mom, sister and her family at my Mom's. They are enjoying what I bring, and my sister is starting to ask for MY recipes. Can you imagine that? She is cooking an occasional Atkins friendly recipe, because THEY LIKED IT when I made it for them! At Christmas the family made their usual food, and I brought Atkins friendly food that EVERYONE ate as well. Cole Slaw, Cheesecake, Fluff, MOCKAFONI and cheese( cauliflower casserole recipe), Veggie dip, and Ham, Turkey cream cheese roll-ups topped with green olives. And there was food they all made that I could eat too. NOT ALL OF IT, but enough to satisfy my hunger, and enjoy as well. I don't think anyone would have even noticed if I did or didn't have a "brownie."


              2- You HAVE to give this plan more than a "couple of days". Goodness gracious---your body needs time to adjust to a new eating plan, ridding itself from crap food, etc. Correct me if I am wrong, but I believe any new weight loss plan introduced to a person gives you a headache (if your are prone to them) when you cut back on sugar, caffeine, and high carb snacks/foods. It is a sugar withdrawal. I got a headache starting WW every time.
              You just have to work through it if you want to reach a goal. If it was easy we would all be stick thin. You need some patience and time to adjust. My first two weeks I was on this board asking so many questions trying to figure it all out. Now, this is a "natural" way of eating for me.

              So please don't give up on yourself just yet. I am sure you are strong enough to get up and running. Use the tools, fitday, recipe links, induction rules and all that good stuff above in the FORUMS section. And ask for help. And keep asking. But you have to help yourself, too. Hang in there for a while, educate yourself with all aspects of the eating plan and WOL, and use the tools. I LOVE FitDay - Free Weight Loss and Diet Journal
              259/206/149
              Start
              8/10/09

              ***Total -53!***



              :dancingba


              Journal
              http://www.atkinsdietbulletinboard.c...ilding-me.html

              Tell us about your weather and where you live...

              http://www.atkinsdietbulletinboard.c...-tomorrow.html

              Challenges
              Goal Met:
              9,10,11,12,02,03 Mileage
              9,10,11,12,01,02,03Water
              10,
              11,12,01,02,03ABS
              12,01,02,03Strength




              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                I agree Atkins isn't for everyone. It doesn't sound like you are ready to make the commitment it takes to do Atkins and that's ok. You know it's here if you ever get to the point you want to make a full commitment to it. If not there are many other programs out there or like you said exercising more and cutting out the majority of the crap will work to get some off. Though you may have a hard time getting to goal on that type of eating because you will always be craving more.

                Good luck in whatever you do and I hope you have a happy and healthy future
                Atkins Start date: 01/18/2010--Now off plan for med reasons, still an Atkins lover!
                Female-37 yrs-4'11"
                HW-240/SW-169/CW-143.0/GW-125

                Mini Goals

                159---Hit 02/08/2010 Woohoo
                149---Hit 03/08/2010 YES!
                139
                129





                Highest weight till now



                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                  Wow!!! I didn't realize I'd get so many responses! I really appreciate it. All the advice and good cheer really warmed my heart. I really appreciate what you said too, Poobears1972.

                  The thing is....I guess at this point in my life what I was REALLY looking for was a quick fix. But that isn't the way to solve any problem, is it? I thought Atkins would be my quick fix. But it really is a lifetime commitment.

                  So here is what I'm going to do: I am going to try to sort out my weight problem psychologically first and do my own thing, as I have never truly faced my weight issues head on. Then, if nothing happens for me in that regard and I really do need to make over the way I eat, I will come back to Atkins. I don't want to return to it as a quick fix. First I just have to follow my gut feeling and sort some things in my head out first.

                  It's nice to know that I am welcome back anytime. I really and trully appreciate it! Good luck to you all....and depending on how things go, I may talk to you all again in the future. Bye for now!!

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                    since you are giving up on your atkins because of your induction issues why don't you try to make your carb choices healthier while you sort out your issues. Giving up white foods could make a huge difference in your weight issues while you don't restrict your carbs to the induction levels. then when you are ready you could just cut a few more starches from your eating and be an Atkins OWLer. Mrs Atkins called it backing into atkins.
                    by the book atkinseer

                    started 6/1/02 at 313
                    goalie 5/04 at 167 with under 15% body fat ADBB Presidents exercise Challenge


                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                      *Mission to loose....I'm not having any issues at the moment with my atkins journey "this time around" because I have done nothing but prepare, prepare & prepare some more, prepare for the week, prepare for the day, I'm thinking of ways to set myself up for sucess all the time! but what I really wanted to say was, your reply to this post was wonderful! it inspired me and I'm going to save it for those days that I just really don't think I can do this....Thanks
                      Amy
                      1st mini goal....to lose 25 pounds (18 gone so far)
                      2nd mini goal...to weigh 199
                      3rd not so mini goal...to weigh 160 (maybe 155)

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                        I have failed on this diet before, too. During my previous attempts I quit because the induction phase made me REALLY sick. This time is no different but I'm doing more to help myself (asprin!!!) and reminding myself that it will pass. I am also hoping that a little pain now will prevent worse things (i.e. diabetes) later. When you finally find that thing that motivates you, try it again. Good luck!
                        SW/CW/GW: 211/210/160
                        5'6", female
                        Start date: 3/9/10

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                          Hello Ultrachic - when the time is right - you'll do what will work best for you. I researched this extensively (I am a Nurse) and the physiology behind this diet is the best. I grew up on home made glazed donuts (Granda was a German baker), streudel, and ice cream. Now thes things almost gag me!
                          As the old saying goes - "Nothing tasts as good as thin feels!"
                          Good luck
                          MooCow
                          57 yo/F/ 5'
                          Starting Weight 164 2/22/10 BMI: OBESE
                          Mini Goals
                          #1 160 3/8/10BMI: "OBESE"
                          #2 155 3/15/10 (152) BMI: "OVERWEIGHT"
                          #3 150
                          #4 145
                          #5 140
                          #6 135
                          #7 130
                          #8 125
                          #9 120
                          GOAL 118
                          [url=http://www.TickerFactory.com/weight-loss/wwLqvMw/]
                          [url=http://www.TickerFactory.com/weight-loss/wrWWiQr/]


                          My final journey to permanent weight loss!

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Call me a quitter....but I just can't do it.

                            Originally posted by ultrachic View Post
                            I thought Atkins would solve all my weight, hunger and craving problems.

                            I was really excited about it and thought it would be very easy to me. Plus in theory, the science behind it sounds very correct.

                            I only lasted a few days on induction twice, and i'm not even sure if I reached ketosis. I did get blinding migraines a few days into it though.

                            But I kept having to scrutinize ingredients in everything, and I didn't realize that so many things have traces of sugar in them (mayo, sausages, cream cheese, etc). I don't want to keep throwing things out because of that.

                            Plus I thought eating the amount of meat and eggs and butter and olive oil that I was eating would keep me full, but I still found I was hungry.

                            Also, I found it quite difficult to make meat flavorful without the use of bbq sauces. My city does not have any place to buy sugar-free sauces, and anything that is sugar-free has aspartame in it. So that makes it quite hard.

                            I also was constantly wondering whether or not I was keeping myself at 20 grams of carbs daily. I kept thinking "If I add these two lettuce leaves and this one tbsp of cream will I be over 20 grams?" "If I put 2 packets of Splenda in my decaf tea will I still be able to have that chunk of green pepper in my salad?"

                            Finally, I have to face this. My heritige is of the East Coast Canadian sort. We are a people who make fish hash with white potatoes and who ate slices of fresh homemade bread wth butter and molasses on the way to school and who enjoy carrots and peas with our Turkey at Christmas and who's mothers made prize-winning pies and brownies. When I was growing up I ate these things and I never ever developed a weight problem until I went away to college and became addicted to fast food and became sedentry.

                            So maybe the thing for me to do is just try and get as much exercise as I can, stop with the fast food, and cut down on the really bad carbs.

                            Kudos to everyone on here who has had success with Atkins, but perhaps you are all made of stronger stuff than I.

                            Good luck to all that are sticking with it, but I'm going to bow out.

                            Ultrachic, Atkins failure.

                            You're not a failure! You sound overwhelmed and that is understandable. I know most ADBB are very by the book but....sometimes it's easier to slide into the low carb diet than to go cold turkey. Pick an amount of carbs you know you can do. Is it 100? 50? 75? Do what you feel comfortable with and go from there. Take what you need from this board and leave the rest. Good luck to you!

                            Comment

                            Working...
                            X