Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

[Slapshot]

In another thread regarding carbs in wine, Megs explained that in Dr. Atkins' last book before he died, Atkins for Life, Dr. Atkins removed wine from the OWL ladder found in DANDR2002.

I had no idea that Atkins for Life modified the DANDR principles, so I'm curious if anyone is aware of any other key additions/deletions/modifications in the Atkins for Life book. Sure, I could go read the book, but...

I think this thread is useful because we all point people toward DANDR2002 as the standard we follow. If there is better, more enlightened, conclusions from Dr. Atkins in Atkins for Life, I think it might be helpful to identify them here so some of us (like me) don't follow something less than Dr. Atkins best work (i.e. I'm now seriously considering my wine intake when I get to the original OWL rung that allowed it).

Thanks everyone for any insights...

[Slapshot]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I'm going to pick up AFL today (too curious not to). I'll report back as I read through it any additional insights I find, or any key distinctions between DANDR2002 and AFL.

Stay tuned.

[not2late]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

AFL is more geared for folks on Atkins Maintenance. So he talks more about the glycemic index of foods.

The alcohol thing is one of the bigger examples of the difference and a greater discussion/emphasis on the glycemic index. But nothing else earth-shaking.

Oh the question might arise, why ADBB follows DANDR2002 and not incorporate some AFL changes.....

I wasn't part of the moderators at the time AFL was published, but from what I understand, the moderators and administrators back then discussed it and decided that we would stick with DANDR 2002 to avoid confusion. See at that time, Atkins Nutritionals Inc. was changing things around: tomatoes were put on the salad veg list and the other list (inspite of its glycemic index), it was okay to eat Atkins brand bread/muffins/cookies during Induction eventhough they contained non-induction thing like oat flour, wheat flour, etc. So they decided to stick to DANDR 2002, otherwise they would be revising the diet themselves.

[Slapshot]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

That makes sense to me. I'm glad there are no earth shattering changes, which just confirms that a sound DANDR2002 is the way to go. As a student of Atkins, I'll pick it up anyway since I'll eventually need to read it as I get to maintenance. Actually, it will help with visualizing myself a year from now when I'm on maintenance, so it will be a good exercise for me to pick it up.

Thanks again for the insights, Megs...

[Desertthorn]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I wouldn't spend my money on it until I was close to Maintenance, if then

[Slapshot]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I wouldn't spend my money on it until I was close to Maintenance, if then

Hmm. Why not? Did you not get anything out of it? (It's not as if it's ever going to be updated....)

[Desertthorn]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I thought it was very little on the WOE pre-maintenance and geared more for after goal, which is fine. If I were you, I would check out the library and see if they had it before I would spend my money on it, then if you like it, you could purchase it. LOL. If I could find my old copy, I would send it to you.

[not2late]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I thought it was very little on the WOE pre-maintenance and geared more for after goal, which is fine. .

That's because it explained Maintenance Atkins in depth, as compared to DANDR.

I remember when it was published alot of newbies were confused because it didn't tell you much about Induction, OWL or Pre-Maintenance.

The useful thing for the weight loss phases is the "eat this" charts in the OWL section of AFL. Elleth copied those charts into an OWL forum stickie.

[momtomany1]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I find the book inspirational, Atkins for Life, and also cautionary. For example, after reading AFL you may really truly accept that you might not be able to eat more than one slice of bread a day for the rest of you life! Or you get used to the idea that if you eat bananas you might be eating them a half a banana at a time once you are maintaining. That is the cautionary part!

But the life stories and explanations of how to make it work long term I found to be just the push I needed to get in the groove and say yep... this is if for me permanently. Definitely not a stand-alone book on how to do Atkins, but excellent for it's purpose... 'the rest of the story.'

[Slapshot]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I thought it was very little on the WOE pre-maintenance and geared more for after goal, which is fine. If I were you, I would check out the library and see if they had it before I would spend my money on it, then if you like it, you could purchase it. LOL. If I could find my old copy, I would send it to you.

Now I know what you mean. I sat in a comfy chair for 20 minutes at Border and read most of it (half the book is recipes). The success stories were great, but nothing new. There really wasn't much new info whatsoever, but still helpful for some folks for confirmation that Atkineering as a WOE is doable and enjoyable. Saved myself the $15.

[SunnySmile501]

Re: Key differences between DANDR 2002 and Atkins for Life.

I really liked it because it goes in-depth on things lightly touched on in DANDR. Lots of info on different fats, and how they affect the body; which to use for cooking and which to only use cold. It is much more geared to making this a healthy "diet" for life. It certainly wouldn't be for anyone just doing Atkins to dump a bunch of weight before vacation. This is for after you have committed to make this a lifestyle change.

There are lots of patient success stories with pictures. Not just the ones that lost all their weight in a couple of months. He included people with severe weight loss challenges and health challenges. I was really inspired by these people.

I think you will get a lot of good from the book. I feel certain that you are on board for life and not just until you lose 50 pounds and fall off and never really get back on.