Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Am I just dumb???

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Am I just dumb???

    Ok, I have the book. I've read the book. I've read induction about 20 times. Maybe I'm just looking too hard, but the bottom line is that I am totally confused! I don't have the book with me, so I can't quote the line, however, I remember reading that you can only have 3 cups of lettuce/salad veg., or 2 cups of lettuce/salad veg. & 1 cup of other vegetables. When I look up the info on iceberg lettuce & spinach leaves, the count is only about 1 carb per cup. Why then can I not have a big salad with my lunch and my dinner! Seriously, 3 cups of lettuce or spinach is a huge salad! So at 6 carbs per day just in salad, why is that not allowed??

    Thank a bundle!
    Rachel
    Rachel

    29/f
    start date: 5/27/08
    sw 344/cw 336/gw 175

    Goals:
    1. 330 (so I can play on our Wii Fit!)
    2. 305 (my weight before I got pregnant in 10/06)
    3. 294 (I want hair extensions!)
    4. 244 (tattoo removal!)
    5. 212 (weight when I met my hubby~I'm thinking Cancun!)
    6. 199 (5th grade was the last time I was under 200)







  • #2
    Re: Am I just dumb???

    Because during induction, you are limiting your veggies to see which ones cause a blood sugar spike (or too many of them) which would cause carb cravings. Dr. Atkins intended for us to be blissfully craving-less during induction =D I am not saying that it WILL induce cravings, but induction is the extreme, just so you can experience what he is wanting us to experience for the first phase of this "diet."
    Andrea
    Age 32/f, 5' 9-1/2"
    Restart 02/16/2010: hw 260/sw257.8/cw239.2/gw165
    18.6 pounds down, 74.2 pounds to go!

    Goal #1: 230
    Goal #2: 220
    Goal #3: 210
    Goal #4: 200
    Goal #5: 190
    Goal #6: 180
    Goal #7: 170
    GOAL: 165 by summer 2011

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Am I just dumb???

      I have wondered about that too and I don't know the answer. I just said to myself "It's only two weeks" Then you can have that big salad because you can have 5 net carbs added and if you do that in lettuce, you will have a huge amount! I will be watching the thread to see if anyone gives an answer. Perhaps it was becuase he wanted us to get more fat? not sure.



      41yo | F | 5'3" | HW: 250+ | CW: 188.4 | GW: 135

      1st Mini Goal Under 200: Met 2/29/08
      2nd Mini Goal Under 190: Met 5/5/08
      3rd Mini Goal 180: | 4th Mini Goal 170: | 4th Mini Goal 160: | 6th Mini Goal 150:

      I have a goal to be 150 by my birthday

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Am I just dumb???

        Gah! I didn't even think about blood sugar spikes. That sounds logical.



        41yo | F | 5'3" | HW: 250+ | CW: 188.4 | GW: 135

        1st Mini Goal Under 200: Met 2/29/08
        2nd Mini Goal Under 190: Met 5/5/08
        3rd Mini Goal 180: | 4th Mini Goal 170: | 4th Mini Goal 160: | 6th Mini Goal 150:

        I have a goal to be 150 by my birthday

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Am I just dumb???

          oh dear i had quite a big salad today!!

          i think i may have gone over my limit then

          x


          SW 180lbs / CW 178lbs / GW 130 / I am 5'4"

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Am I just dumb???

            Iceberg lettuce is iceberg Lettuce, it is just ONE vegetable on the "salad" list. It is not "salad" in the entirety.

            There are something like 54 vegetables on the "salad" list and many of them have far more carbohydrate AND TASTE AND TEXTURE than does iceberg lettuce. Make different choices for your two cups of "salad" than iceberg lettuce.
            ~Joy

            Start 1/2/06 Goal 6/11/07 restart 1/2/09
            268.5/196/185
            QUIT SMOKING JULY 23, 2006 while on Atkins


            Just when you think you've eaten enough vegetables...EAT SOME MORE!
            http://www.fitday.com/WebFit/PublicJournals.html?Owner=ride2joy

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Am I just dumb???

              Definitely try the other veggies on the Salad veggies list. Iceberg and even Romain lettuce are probably providing the least nutrition to your body during the induction period. It's basically "chewy water". Try the other items on the list too....experiment!!
              Higgies
              ----------------------

              (Wish I still looked that good! LOL!)
              33 y/o - Male
              1st go around Started: 7/29/2004, Made Goal: 03/17/2005 HW: 286 / GW: 195 / Went off Atkins June, 2008
              2nd Go Around: Started 1/4/2010 SW: 239/ CW: 233/ GW: 220

              Comment

              Working...
              X