Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

    I'm not exactly sure where to post this so feel free to move this wherever...

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20051205/...tuitive_eating

    SALT LAKE CITY - When Steven Hawks is tempted by ice cream bars, M&Ms and toffee-covered almonds at the grocery store, he doesn't pass them by. He fills up his shopping cart.

    It's the no-diet diet, an approach the Brigham Young University health science professor used to lose 50 pounds and to keep it off for more than five years.

    Hawks calls his plan "intuitive eating" and thinks the rest of the country would be better off if people stopped counting calories, started paying attention to hunger pangs and ate whatever they wanted.

    As part of intuitive eating, Hawks surrounds himself with unhealthy foods he especially craves. He says having an overabundance of what's taboo helps him lose his desire to gorge.

    There is a catch to this no-diet diet, however: Intuitive eaters only eat when they're hungry and stop when they're full.

    That means not eating a box of chocolates when you're feeling blue or digging into a big plate of nachos just because everyone else at the table is.

    The trade-off is the opportunity to eat whatever your heart desires when you are actually hungry.

    "One of the advantages of intuitive eating is you're always eating things that are most appealing to you, not out of emotional reasons, not because it's there and tastes good," he said. "Whenever you feel the physical urge to eat something, accept it and eat it. The cravings tend to subside. I don't have anywhere near the cravings I would as a 'restrained eater.'"
    All I can say is this is exactly how I used to eat. I'm not an emotional eater and I don't snack between meals. I ate only when I was hungry and stopped when I was full enough to get me through to the next meal. I hardly ever stuffed myself. Though I ate more than the average Filipino I believe I eat around the same as the average American as I am an inch below the average American height.

    From personal experience, at best, intuitive eating helped me maintain my weight, but failed to do so whenever a lifestyle change occured. This usually happened when I changed jobs. I would intuitively eat according to my previous lifestyle instead of my new one. This would result in weight gain.

    There's probably more to this intuitive eating than what is written in the articl, and it probably works or people with normal metabolisms and have no issues with trigger foods and emotional eating. But how many of us here are in that category.

    One thing that Atkins has proven to me, especially during the OWL phase, is that what I put into my body matters a lot more than how much.
    Robbie T., 240/180/160. 41yr Male, Height 5'9"
    Started November 1, 2003. Minor goal (180lbs.) reached Oct. 30, 2004
    Lowest weight before slacking-off : 175lbs
    Quezon City, Philippines
    "Eppur si muove!"

  • #2
    Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

    (*sigh*) Well, goody for him...if I could "only eat when they're hungry and stop when they're full" I wouldn't be overweight now...so his little diet won't be helping me!

    And as far as surrounding yourself with forbidden foods, living in the US, I don't know how much more surrounded we could possibly be. Isn't that overabundance of crap food the largest part of the growing obesity problem?
    Shelly

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

      Well, goody for him...if I could "only eat when they're hungry and stop when they're full"
      Me too me too! I can't eat just one.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

        Eating like that, I wonder if he was doing extensive exercising or something to get the original 50 pounds off? I know I was addicted to salt and anything that had a salty taste was my choice. Chips, Pretzels, Popcorn...were probably my worst culprits. If they were in the house, I ate them. This diet would never have worked with me!
        Starting Date 3/12/04 285/165/145 - F



        Dedication gives wings to our dreams and keeps them in flight! In One Word...COMMITTMENT.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

          Unfortunately the problem is that many of us (myself included) don't know when enough food is really enough food.

          Pre-Atkins I used to eat 2 cups of pasta along with 2 or 3 slices of bread for one meal. 1/2 cup pasta is a serving. 1 slice of bread is a serving. So in that one meal I was eating 4 servings of pasta and 2 or 3 servings of bread. Add that to my 2 breakfast bagels (1/4 of a bagel is 1 serving, so I had 8 servings of grains for my breakfast) and the bread/rice/pasta I ate at lunch. That was great: I got my 9-11 servings of grains the USDA said I was suppose to have. 2 bagels "filled me up". As did the 2 cups of pasta plus the bread. But I was overeating because I didn't know the difference between "satisfied" and "full".

          With Atkins, I learned to get my appetite under control. I re-learned all those natural satiety cues I unlearned over the years. Now, 1 slice of a double fiber bread is just the right amount as is a 1/2 cup low carb pasta. It's also satisfying too because I never can bring myself to eat both of those things at the same meal, let alone on the same day.

          ~Megs~
          242/141/160 (130)
          dress size 26/10/8
          5'4", Female, May 2, 2003
          My blog:
          http://mformiscellaneous.blogspot.com/

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

            I have real issues with the concept for a couple reasons:

            1. Where's the nutritional value in keeping a pantry filled with M&M's and a fridge stocked with junk?

            2. Debra Waterhouse, in her book Outsmarting the Female Fat Cell, discussed the whole intuitive eating concept back in '93!

            3. A person shouldn't eat until full, but until they are no longer hungry. Being full means they overstretched their stomach fullness receptors and ate beyond satiety and beyond what the body needs. When it takes 20 minutes to register fullness, people overeat especially.

            4. A lot of what he eats is high glycemic index and goes right to the blood sugar so he's going to be hungry more often and eat more.

            It sounds like a mad-cap diet that M&M Mars put together.
            ADBB Moderator Emeritus
            My blog: The Lighter Side of Low Carb: Food, fun and fidgeting
            Low Carb Lolitas: Hip low carb bloggers

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Professor Loses Weight With No-Diet Diet

              This is certainly not a new concept. In my many attempts to lose weight, I tried this approach back in 1988 after reading a book called "Overcoming Overeating". I ended up gaining about 30 pounds and kept them for many years.

              I tried again when I started reading books by Geneen Roth, whose plan is essentially the same thing. It simply doesn't work for me. I'm not the type who can sit around analyzing my own bellybutton, looking for clues to my behaviour. The urge to eat and overeat is too overwhelming for me to resist no matter how I try to tell myself I'm not really "hungry".

              Even now, Atkins has changed my life for the better, but I find my eating behaviors much the same. I just eat different food and it causes me less damage. I'm not sure I ever feel totally in control. If I were, I'd have been able to lose the last 30 pounds. But I won't give up.
              Laurie
              52-yr old female, 5'7"
              229/138/138


              Comment

              Working...
              X