Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

    I sometimes find it hard to identify with or understand what other people are reporting as their diet experiences. I don't crave carbs, I never did. It's always been meat that I can eat way, way too much of. I took to Atkins like the proverbial duck to water, and while I did lose significant weight on it, I'd be doing it faster and better if I didn't have as insidious a meat/fat craving as other people report sugar/carb cravings. Limiting my portions can be extremely difficult.

    I did Atkins for nearly two years and never got tired of meat with a bit of veg on the side. I switched over to a bodybuilder's diet for awhile, and I had no problems with the carbs as they didn't trigger cravings. Neither did what I was eating for protein (steamed chicken breasts, water pack tuna and whey protein mostly). My food sucked a lot and I hated the diet, but it did what it needed to do at the time.

    Now that my schedule doesn't allow for regular lifting, I'm back on Atkins for the second time around. I am finding that if I'm not careful, I'll eat a big hunk of meat and ignore everything else because I could care less if it's there or not. I zero in on whatever meat is on the plate, snarf it down, look for more, and then maybe think about the veggies.

    Now when I cook some low carb specialties to tempt the boyfriend who's doing Atkins for his first time around, those are tasty enough to earn a bit of voluntary room on my plate. But when he's not around, it's a handful of raw veggies and a chunk of meat, and that suits me fine. I watch other people eat bread and sweets and I really don't care. Give me more meat please. Lots of meat. Lots and lots of meat. Hot and sizzling with fat on the outside, half raw and blue on the inside, juicy and delicious, with a flavorful sprinkling of sea salt and a grind of fresh black pepper. A crisply roasted duck, its skin just barely seared to crackling and the breast pink and rare on the inside, with just a few leaves of arugula or watercress, will do very nicely. I need nothing else to be perfectly content.

    Anyhow you see my problem. Atkins works very well indeed for most people because they have a limited appetite for meat and fat. It still works well even for me, but it would probably work even better if I was more scrupulous about eating my minimum portions of vegetables. But this meat craving makes life on Atkins both extremely pleasant and a bit frustrating, because portion control is significantly more difficult for me on Atkins than it is on a diet that doesn't feed my meat and fat cravings enough to kick them into high gear.

    Anyone else have issues with hardcore meat and fat craving, or am I alone here? It isn't at all hard for me to stick to the diet. I literally don't desire anything but meat with plenty of fat on it. A bit of crisp salad is nice for a change of texture, and the bitterness of greens like arugula and watercress make a wonderful taste complement to fatty meat. But it's not even all that necessary to my palate when there's meat and plenty of it. Gourmet food does tempt me for taste value, but meat and fat is a primal, fundamental physical craving.

    I already know what advice I'm going to give myself - exercise better portion control and eat my veggies first, not as an afterthought. What I want to know is if anyone else is a primary "meat craver" who has very little interest in carbs but far too much interest in meat.

  • #2
    Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

    Congratulations on identifying your issue. I enjoy meat as well, and occasionally have trouble fitting in some veggies. It is important to get those in, though. If you don't exercise portion control, you will end up with protein being converted to fat, which will definitely slow you down. You sound like you know what you're doing and will take steps to make that happen. Your knowledge of your issue and how you are approaching it is inspirational.
    Rick
    38 - Male - Houston
    Restarting 1/4/10

    250/245/200

    If you continue to do as you've always done, you will continue to get what you've always got.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

      i can definitely over due it on meat as well. Roast, sausage and bacon, bacon is the easiest for me to over due! I can put away a whole package in less that 12 hours if i don't stop myself! something about the crispy melty in your mouth goodness i love it!
      i don't really crave carbs anymore but i still can over eat legal stuff to easily.
      sorry im not much help!
      p.s. i've been drinking lots and lots of water lately!

      restarted 7/23/09 HW 338/SW 280/ CW 261.2/ GW 185 37yrs/5'11

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

        I'm a meat lover as well, the only thing I crave equally is CHEESE! I love a Big Fat Ribeye with the fat! The fat is the best part! I could eat just chicken (with the skin of course) or just steak for a meal with no problem, or even seafood, We often have just crablegs with butter for dinner with nothing else! I do like veggies too, but I could not eat a meal just of veggies like I can with meat.


        5'4"
        45 yrs (F) a.k.a. "Butterbean"
        Start date 5/18/2003
        197/163.5/130

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

          Naja, I can relate to your story. I'm not much of a veggie person either. In fact, I'm a self-proclaimed veggie-hater, but I AM working on improving that. As far as meat goes, yup, the fattier the better. I've always craved a ribeye or prime rib over a filet minon any day. Giving up carbs wasn't that difficult. There were a few that I did enjoy though, but over all, doing Atkins WOE has not been difficult.

          You're right in that you need to up your veggie consumption, but you also have to realize that Atkins is a high fat diet, not a high protein diet. Have you tried using fitday.com to track your food intake? As long as you are in the 65%/30%/5% fat/protein/carbs ratio, you're ok!!!

          Let us know of your progress!!!
          HW=250+/222/GW=175 37F/5'7
          Revamped my WOL starting 2/10/08.










          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

            meat, veggies it doesn't mater to me. I can overeat it all if I let myself. I can eat the whole roast whenit comes out of the oven unless i control myself cause there are no meat crvings going on just wants and um boy does this taste good.
            by the book atkinseer

            started 6/1/02 at 313
            goalie 5/04 at 167 with under 15% body fat ADBB Presidents exercise Challenge


            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

              The only meat I have a problem with--that is, the only meat that I causes me to lose all my appetite suppression-- is pork chops. I can eat and eat and eat pork chops and still have room for more. No other cut of pork or other meat affects me like that.
              ~Megs~
              242/141/160 (130)
              dress size 26/10/8
              5'4", Female, May 2, 2003
              My blog:
              http://mformiscellaneous.blogspot.com/

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                Thanks all, I don't feel quite so alone now. Last time around I posted about this and people looked at me like I was nuts and talked about their carb cravings.

                It's not protein that actually does it for me. In fact on the bodybuilder's diet regiment when I was eating only lean protein like steamed chicken breasts or water pack tuna, I had no desire to overeat those foods. It's animal fat that triggers the urge to overeat. So a nice juicy fatty steak or duck with the skin on, that is what I'll eat way too much of. I'm aware of how the protein to glucose conversion works (in fact I use that principle when I lift for maintenance while low carbing), but it's not protein I'm really in danger of eating too much of. It's fat, animal fat to be specific.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                  how about only eating leanercuts of meat or cutting off all visible fats before cooking?
                  by the book atkinseer

                  started 6/1/02 at 313
                  goalie 5/04 at 167 with under 15% body fat ADBB Presidents exercise Challenge


                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                    That would probably work, but it would make the diet as annoying, un-enjoyable and as difficult to sustain for me as any of the strict bodybuilder regimens I've been on. I can do it, but once I do that, I might as well go back to 1/4 cup of raw oats and whey protein for breakfast, an apple for a midday snack, a steamed chicken breast, spinach and half a small sweet potato for lunch, 4 oz water pack tuna with salad greens for a pre-dinner snack and another steamed chicken breast with broccoli and brown rice for dinner. I lose weight even faster on that regimen, especially when doing intense workouts, and it seriously sucks to be me when I'm doing it.

                    Atkins minus the fatty meat might actually be harder for me to sustain than the strict bodybuilder's cutting diet, since the low fat/moderate carb/high protein/restricted calorie diet does not trigger any of my food cravings. Food is so boring and I'm stuffing nasty crap in my face so often that I don't want to overeat. I can stand that kind of diet for awhile when I'm doing something towards a muscle-building goal, but it isn't sustainable in the long run and I can't do it at all when I'm this short on time.

                    The big advantage of Atkins for me is that it's so incredibly easy and natural for me to stay on. No temptations for forbidden foods whatsoever, as long as I get plenty of meat and fat. Three widely spaced meals of mostly meat and fat a day gives me the energy to stay moving on an intense, physically demanding schedule for long hours. Also I have an endless source of meat from home butchering and hunting, so it's ideally suited to my lifestyle.

                    I may be able to switch a higher percentage of my fat needs over to vegetable and dairy foods that do not trigger my cravings, but the suckage factor there for me personally is likely to be higher than going back to raw oats, whey protein and steamed chicken breasts. Animal fat for me is like potato chips to other people - bet you can't eat just one. Cow, that is.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                      I do the same thing. You have to eat your vegetables FIRST! I'm a meat lover from W A A Y back grew up on a farm and we raised and butchered our own, so it was always good and tender and tasty. I'm lucky, I love vegetables, but I'd go for the meat furst every time. I now force myself to eat my vegetables and THEN eat the meat. You woll have to do this if the diet is going to work. And make the portions a bit smaller than you think you'll get through, so there is room in your tum for the vegetables. Be disciplined and you can fight this off.
                      Odille

                      Start 10 Sep 05
                      F, 170cm (5'7"); 53
                      ----------------------------
                      I lost 11kg or 25.4lbs in 14 days on Induction!
                      131 kg (HW/est SW)/ 104.3 (CW)/ 63 (GW)
                      288.5 lbs / 223.5 / 138 (1kg = 2.202 lbs)
                      www.noworriesoz.biz







                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                        Yeah, I have to admit, I'm a meat lover too.... I could just give the veggies, especially since I can't eat potatoes, the toss and just eat meat all of the time. So, I have a hard time getting enough carbs in on this WOE, no problem with the protein. I have to make a concious effort to eat my veggies, but I do. Lunch is my main veggie meal... nice good salad with lots of raddish, pepper, broccoli, etc... but for dinner I could easily just do hot wings or sometihng like that. Again, I am working on it to make this work.

                        Rick
                        Male, 51 years old
                        Start Date 12/30/2005
                        250/189/190
                        Original goal: Lose 30 lbs by Mar. 1st, 2006. I made it!!!

                        Calling it GOAL at this point. I'm happy with where I am now and hope to stay there, or maybe even take it down a little more.


                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                          I notice that I tend to want to over eat higher fat meats like steak, hot wings in butter and hot sauce, fried chicken with the skin, bacon...mmm now I'm hungery lol
                          Restarting again 193/174/130

                          My Journal Here, Please Stop by: http://www.atkinsdietbulletinboard.c...ad.php?t=24453
                          >>GOAL of 136 8/5/2006

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                            Yup, same here, I have always kinda shrugged when people were going on and on about craving carbs, I don't do carbs, hehe, I crave meat and fat, I even found a solution for the steamed chickenbreast, heh, I eat it with mayonaise, hmmmmmm, that really is my biggest problem; eating fatty foods, even cream.
                            I am forever on this plateau being around 170 lbs (since the beginning of july now) and I think biggest problem is that I do enjoy overeating on fatty meats and such sometimes, like as a special treat sometimes.
                            I DO use fitday and actually I am almost always around 5/30/65 and hardly ever over 2000 calories and still I think that is the problem, I dunno..........
                            41 year old female, lenght 5'5'' and a half

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Am I alone here? Meat craving is my diet issue

                              It's true! I can eat 30 hot wings and not bat an eyelash!


                              I got into vegetables by putting bacon on top of them (e.g. smashed cauliflower) or cubed meat in them (e. g. chef salads).

                              But god... some days I just want to eat a couple dozen wings and pass out on my couch.
                              No stats. Not weighing anymore ever. Will post "before and after" pictures when I want to. The end.

                              Vigilance, not perfection.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X