Low Carb Shake

[lincspoacher]

Im have just finished day 15, but still maintaining induction.

I bought 4 low carb shakes today that contain

water, milk protein, etc and state that each 330ml carton only has 0.5g net carbs.

On the table of info it states 0.3 staurates and 0.1 polyols.

It has 9g of fat.

Is this ok to drink in induction?

[not2late]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Im have just finished day 15, but still maintaining induction.

I bought 4 low carb shakes today that contain

water, milk protein, etc and state that each 330ml carton only has 0.5g net carbs.

On the table of info it states 0.3 staurates and 0.1 polyols.

It has 9g of fat.

Is this ok to drink in induction?

Over the last almost 4 years ADBB has been on the Net, it has been our collective experience that low carb bars, shakes and other foods can slow or completely stop weight loss in some people. Therefore, we do not recommend their use during the Induction phase.

As for the shake information, what's the rest of the nutritional profile? That is how many calories, grams of protein, and grams of total carbs does it have?

[LuckyD]

Re: Low Carb Shake

I am out of induction and I drink the shakes occasionally for breakfast. I have an early job, and 4 kids to get ready for school, so sometimes making breakfast or even eating breakfast is just not an option. So I drink them maybe 2 times a week if even that. I am still losing weight so they haven't stalled me. I think it is a personal thing and you have to see how they are going to effect you. Real food is the best. But it is always good to have another option when you need one.

[ttdriver]

Re: Low Carb Shake

I drank the EAS Carb Control shakes through induction without a problem. Not saying everyone should, but it never stalled or hindered my losses at all.


Betty

[not2late]

Re: Low Carb Shake

I'm sure there are people here who drank endless cups of regular coffee or cases of Diet Coke during Induction and still lost weight.....but we don't recommend that at ADBB either.

[ttdriver]

Re: Low Carb Shake

So true, Megs!!


Betty

[Brook]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Megs, you crack me up! Well said!!

I'd be curious to know what the ingredients in those shakes are, as well as the nutritional profile.

Because this was brought up I'd like to respond to it quickly:

If you plan ahead, you never have to worry about morning options. Knowing where your trouble zones/times are is more than half the battle and planning around them is a good portion of the rest of it.

My 3 kids need breakfast before they go to school, and I'm not about to fill them full of food I know and view as unhealthy for me - so we eat breakfast; a healthy breakfast! If that means we have to get up 10 minutes earlier, well then...so be it. Part of the deal in all this is lifestyle adjustments that are condusive to the big picture - and part of the deal for me in my home with my kids is teaching them good habits so they're never in the same position I was in 5 years ago!

Now, I *do* drink protein shakes, but they're made from scratch here at home No eye of gnute/wing of bat/chloropsuedopartiallyhydrogenatedbenzoateneedadegr eeinchemicalengineeringtopronouncetheingredients stuff in them at all heh

[LuckyD]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Its all fine and well to say plan ahead, but sometimes its just not an option. Sometimes 'life' happens and you are unprepared for whatever reason. My mornings are complicated due to a few different reasons and every now and again, I just dont have time to make breakfast, nor do I want to eat whatever food I have prepared that is inthe fridge. I think it is unrealistic to expect prefect diligence 100% of the time. That being said, I would never keep drinking the shakes if they messed me up. But they don't so why shouldn't I take advantage of easiness of them when I am in a time crunch? Of course they are made with yucky stuff, of course I would rather eat real food, of course I don't advocate people drinking them. My point is if helps and it doesnt hurt, why not?

[Brook]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Its all fine and well to say plan ahead, but sometimes its just not an option. Sometimes 'life' happens and you are unprepared for whatever reason. My mornings are complicated due to a few different reasons and every now and again, I just dont have time to make breakfast, nor do I want to eat whatever food I have prepared that is inthe fridge. I think it is unrealistic to expect prefect diligence 100% of the time.

Heh. I'm the *last* person you have to tell about "life happening" around here. - But I make sure I'm NOT unprepared because life does happen. Knowing that that's how some mornings go is exactly why I find it unrealistic to fly by the seat of my pants. And I'm still not feeding my kids crap because it's convenient for me.

Life is complicated. <shrug> So what? I can use that as an excuse or I can accept that challenge. I choose to accept the challenge!

No one expects perfect dillegence - but if someone can plan enough ahead to make sure they've got shakes on hand, there's no reason why the following can't be on hand either :

Plastic microwave pans for 3 minute omelettes (with prepped ingredients, of course)
Prepared jicama for jicama and cream.
Dinner left overs.
Boiled eggs and sliced deli meats.
Berries/melons/etc all ready to roll with cottage cheese (*not* induction appropriate).
etc, etc, etc.

Wouldn't you agree?

That being said, I would never keep drinking the shakes if they messed me up. But they don't so why shouldn't I take advantage of easiness of them when I am in a time crunch? Of course they are made with yucky stuff, of course I would rather eat real food, of course I don't advocate people drinking them. My point is if helps and it doesnt hurt, why not?

If you're okay with that, that's great. If you have the time, experience, and body-knowledge to know that they don't affect you, then more power to you. 99.9% of the newbies that come here to ADBB do *not* have that knowledge of their bodies or of the products. They don't understand that sugar alcohols *do* impact blood sugar, they don't understand the whole concept of 'net carbs' and how to count them, and they don't understand that the ingredients in those shakes are NOT induction appropriate.

Feeding my body "yucky stuff" and being comfortable with that is part of what landed me with a ginormous butt. It's part of the "instant gratification" and "fly by the seat of my pants" mindset that set me up for failure after failure after failure. I'd say that attitude and perspective certainly did hurt and not help! If that's not you - again - that's fantastic.

I'm here to show the newbies that it CAN be done, there are NO excuses for half-assing it, and give suggestions to further illustrate the point.

Keep on keepin' on and much success to you.
~Brook

[LuckyD]

Re: Low Carb Shake

I dont remember ever saying that I fed my kids crap. And I certainly do not 'fly by the seat of pants'. I was simply answering a question someone started this thread with, and yet somehow I have been made to feel I am inadequate because I drink a shake now and again. I know the alternatives and believe me I eat them. But sometimes I like to just pop a can in my purse and drink it when I ca. I really dont need to feel somehow a lesser person for that. What if some people cant do this WOE without an occasional shake? Should they abandon the whole thing because they cant live up to your standards? I know the board doesn't recommend the shakes. I know they are a no no on induction. But jeez louise, dont make people feel bad about how they live their lives. You know absolutley nothing about me other than sometimes I have a shake in the morning.

[Brook]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Wow.

Defensive much?

I'm trying to understand *why* you'd choose to feed your children something healthy and then forego it yourself??

If you're feeling inadequate, that's on you. I most certainly made no implication in that direction. If I thought you were a lesser person for whatever reason, I'm just creepy enough to tell you. LOL I don't know you from Adam. Chill out. No one insulted you.

"Can't" and "won't" are two entirely different things. Saying someone "can't" do this WOE without an occasional shake is crap no matter who you are or how you look at it. It's a choice. If that's a choice that someone makes, that's fine - then claim the choice and own the choice, but don't pass it off with a weak "I can't" or "I had no choice". Yes you can. Yes you did.

Who on earth is talking about abandoning anything, let alone *my* standards?! Good grief. Drama much?

They're not recommended for induction. They're not recommended by anyone who is dilligent in eating REAL food. There are TONS of better choices. Excuses about how and why are exactly that, excuses. <shrug> Doesn't make anyone bad. Doesn't make anyone "lesser of a person". Viable alternatives have been listed and posted, not only on this thread, but all over this board. If you make an excuse and don't own it, then don't get bent when you're called out on it.

To further illustrate my point:

No Excuses

Like I said. I know alllll about excuses.

But jeez louise, dont make people feel bad about how they live their lives. You know absolutley nothing about me other than sometimes I have a shake in the morning.

Tread carefully here. I didn't attack you. When I post I strive to maintain the standard of "Hard on ideas, soft on people." - And that's exactly what I did.

Have a nice night.
~Brook

[LuckyD]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Brook, I am not defensive nor am I super sensitive. You're just hyper critical (even if you dont think your are. You certainly come off that way). I am at perfect ease with myself, my family and this WOE. I think you need to reread your posts. They are dripping of self-satisfaction and condescension. Maybe you dont realize this, and I kind of hope that is the case.

[Brook]

Re: Low Carb Shake

Brook, I am not defensive nor am I super sensitive. You're just hyper critical (even if you dont think your are. You certainly come off that way). I am at perfect ease with myself, my family and this WOE. I think you need to reread your posts. They are dripping of self-satisfaction and condescension. Maybe you dont realize this, and I kind of hope that is the case.

LMAO. So now you're name-calling?

Seriously?

*shrug*

I find excuses weak.
I find "can't"s weaker.

If some find that condescending, I'd say that's more reflective of a guilty conscious for being less than proactive than me being self-satisfied.

Perhaps if you took the time to learn about the people that make up the community that you've recently joined, -that have been here for years and have been successful for the long term- you'd understand why we're protective of our WOE, the newbies that come in asking questions that we've answered literally hundreds of times, and you'd know that as one of those long timers around here .....I can be accused of many things - but self satisfaction isn't one of them.

Although....I *am* snarky - and I'll own that one.

For the record, I read everything twice before I post it, but thank you for the suggestion.

I'm going to suggest that some prep work get done now for the morning so breakfast isn't an issue instead of swapping snark back and forth. And to up the ante, I'll take my own advice.

Tomorrow morning: Mock cinnamon apples and cream. Mmmmm.

Good night
~Brook

[LuckyD]

Re: Low Carb Shake

I apologize to everyone who have read this thread. Didn't mean for the soap opera. I have tremendous respect and admiration for the people on this board. This is a wonderful place to come to get support. That is why I am here. I have seen very forgiving people on this board that are in no way preachy or self righteous or defensive, just helpful and understanding. Those are the people that make this board worth coming to.
Again, I apologize if I offended anyone with my remarks. This exchange should have happened in a PM. But I really didn't think it would carry on so far.

[lincspoacher]

Re: Low Carb Shake

If it helps, I drank one last night.............it tastes crap!

3 LO CARB SHAKES NOW IN THE BIN!