Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Disbelief of Atkins

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Disbelief of Atkins

    There is a thread that was written on 4/2 on how a gentelman was quitting Atkins WOE because of kidney problems and a person he knows is in the hospital for kidney failure; and how others have told him it is not safe, or a healthy way of eating, etc..... There were many comments posted to this thread, all supporting the Atkins WOE. He was going to try WW. I tried WW a year ago. I thought it was ridiculous to pay to get weighed and I was ALWAYS hungry. I stopped after a month.
    Here is what I have learned in my lengthy stay (2 weeks ) on Atkins.
    I was very skeptical on doing Atkins. I too had heard that all you do is eat butter, bacon, cheesburgers, cream cheese......... but I couldn't ignore the fact that even if this WAS true, people were still losing weight on this plan. That made me curious. I researched the **** out of this plan and had read enough info that at least resolved me to buy the DANDR book. I was amazed at how scientific this plan was. Atkins theory (now fact) showed how the metabolism will work. The induction phase is strict but I realized that, that was what I thought the whole diet was! And that is what the non-believers think it is also! When I read the OWL section, I thought that was ingenious on how to determine your carb level. But the general public does NOT know this part. They only here or see about the Induction part. They assume that is the whole plan and it is NOT a balanced way of eating. They are right to some extent. But only in the beginning. That is why we take a multi vitamin.
    I had an uncle say to me the other day that "wow, after two weeks you lost 11 pounds? You will never be able to eat like that for even a year". He is convinced that what I eat on Induction is what I have to do for the rest of my life. Even though I have explained to him about the ladder on OWL, he doesn't grasp it. Neither does the general public.
    Reading the book is when it all makes sense.
    Unfortunately the skeptics will not do that, so they stay mis-informed.
    After only two weeks of Induction, most of my aches and pains I have had for years are gone. I feel "physically balanced".
    They stay mis-informed...... Pity.

    Male



  • #2
    Re: Disbelief of Atkins

    You hit the nail on the head my friend.
    Scooter







    Remember this everyday - Something Wonderful Is Going To Happen Today. If you live by that decree you will live life to the fullist.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Disbelief of Atkins

      You're pretty darn smart (and informed) for a new guy. Thanks for your thoughts.
      F/37/5'7" ~ Started: 8/1/06.
      Links: My Journal~ On "loose" skin

      sigpic

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Disbelief of Atkins

        Exactly what I have thought all along ---The Nay sayers about Atkins have no idea what they are talking about! Poor Misinformed lot !!!
        Donna
        F ~
        SW 93 kilos
        CW 64 kilos
        GW 65 kilos http://www.atkinsdietbulletinboard.com/gallery/files/1/3/8/4/9/ADBBGOAL.jpg[/img
        It does not matter how slow you go so long as you dont stop .....Confucious

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Disbelief of Atkins

          Well said Buddyjay! Thanks for having done your "homework" properly and for your vote of confidence, which I and many others on this board endorse 100%. Posts like these put things in perspective (or is it prospective?) for those who might be uneasy.
          Before and after:






          PLEDGING FLIGHTS
          Completed: 1st set of buildings and mountains (Everest,M.Blanc & Kilimanjaro, twice); Tower Masts & Chimneys; More virtual buildings; Challenger's Choice x 2 (volcanos and mountains on Mars). Currently climbing: Mount Snowdon again: 416/475

          Start 10 Jan 2005. Maintenance since Aug. 2005.
          F/56yrs/5'.4"
          SW:77.7 LW:56.5 CW:60.1 (kilos)

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Disbelief of Atkins

            Exactly! If someone starts bashing Atkins (or low carb in general) I tell them to read the book, THEN talk to me.
            ~Brandi
            35/F/5'8", Type 2 Diabetic
            July 27, 2003: 145/ Aug 31: 135/ Goal: 125
            Fell off the wagon in Nov 2003
            Restarted several times since then
            June 2009 168.. Lost 15 lbs after starting work
            Feb 24, 2010:153/139/130-135ish
            size 14/10-12/8









            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Disbelief of Atkins

              I had an uncle say to me the other day that "wow, after two weeks you lost 11 pounds? You will never be able to eat like that for even a year".
              Who could resist a challenge like that? I'm sure you'll show him by your lifestyle that Atkins not only works, but is very liveable! Good work!
              Laurie
              52-yr old female, 5'7"
              229/138/138


              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                Great Post, thanks for pointing that out to some who are still a little weary!



                BEFORE





                NOW

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                  I carry a copy of the book with me to show anyone with an inquiring mind how disillusioned the public has been based on 1990's Atkins info and proliferation of rumors ever since.


                  Note - Make sure you have the 2002 edition, which Dr. Atkins revised completely since the earlier version.
                  ~Susan
                  49/f 5'7" Start 2-27-06 SW222/11-18-09 @ 160-ish/G135-150ish??

                  Doin Miles, Flights, & Kid Ketchin'...
                  2 Ab Chal's; 6WEC#27 slug-Free; & more; 50# LOST in'06-
                  but regained ~20# in '07 in less than 3 weeks! And again early '08 ...Was in HEAVEN -got to 150, for awhile, then got too busy, and gave in too much... and... OK holding pattern "keep it together..."

                  .................OMG how did I fail AGAIN
                  (((on temporary break)))
                  Sigh ... I'll be back... life isn't always fair 10-07-09

                  "Goal: First you have to dream of it. Then you have to do it." Author unknown

                  sheesh

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                    Originally posted by Tiggerdagibit
                    Exactly! If someone starts bashing Atkins (or low carb in general) I tell them to read the book, THEN talk to me.
                    I would be the one he is referring to, and I have read the book cover to cover and followed every step. So I am bashing Atkins. It is possible to lose weight on another diet. I did lose approx 15 pounds in a month, so the diet can work and I am happy with the results. But I have come to realize that the diet and the WOE is just not for me. In all honesty I really don't even need to be on atkins, I just tried it to lose a quick twenty pounds before summer and to prepare for my wedding in April. My physician told me on my last check up that I could afford to lose 20-30 pounds other than that I was fine the way I am. So you all can continue to bash me, but I am not the one that is 400lbs with a eating disorder with no hope. In my post all I said was the diet was not for me and wished everybody good luck on all of their weight loss goals. I love to see overweight people lose a lot weight. They just feel so good about themselves, and it is great to see them happy again. I just love success. So you all can preach the diet and how great it is, but in all honesty I really don't care. Adios..
                    Male
                    35
                    6' 1"
                    270/264/220 down 6
                    270/258/220 down 12

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                      Weird, he doesn't care and is quitting, yet still comes here and posts.


                      ETA: I don't think you need to be 400lbs to have an eating disorder.
                      30/f
                      Some helpful links:
                      Linda's recipe website: http://www.genaw.com/lowcarb/recipes.html


                      Time for Goals!
                      Lose another 10lbs by May 7th CHECK!
                      Lose another 10lbs by May 30th CHECK!
                      Lose another 10lbs by July 31st!! CHECK!
                      Lose another 10lbs By Aug 31st!
                      Lose another 10lbs
                      Lose another 10lbs

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                        Yeah...just leave if you want to...I had an eating disorder when I was at my skinniest..not now...live and let live...
                        F44yrs young 5'7" SW172/CW152/GW140
                        restart date december 08, 2009!
                        1st mini-goal: 160 lbs - reached Jan 05, 2010
                        2nd mini-goal: 155 lbs - reached Feb 02, 2010
                        3rd mini-goal: 150 lbs
                        4th mini-goal: 145 lbs
                        GOAL : 140 lbs :chillpill:dancingba:dancing:

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                          Interesting. He reminds me of a child running away from home ...."I'm leaving... really.... I'm leaving...don't try to stop me. .....I won't be back ..... you'll be sorry when I'm gone"

                          *SIGH*

                          For the most part, we're all adults (respecful nod to the teenagers on board).

                          CapeMay....you're an adult. You've made a decision. Great. Wonderful. Good luck with that. I can't imagine why you'd continue to return, unless - somewhere- you're looking to have someone talk you out of it?

                          A wise person once said "Never discuss religion or politics in polite company - you'll never change their opinion, and they won't change yours".

                          I guess we can add DIETS to that list....


                          Restart -10/18/2009 - 204.6 lbs (UGH!!!)
                          Goal 1 - under 200 - met 10/19/2009
                          Goal 2 - 190 - met 10/25/2009
                          Goal 3 - 180
                          Goal 4 - 170
                          Goal 5 - 160
                          Goal 6 - 150
                          Goal 7 - 140
                          Goal 8 - 135
                          Goal - To zip up current pants without sucking it in-10/25/09
                          Goal - To need a belt/roll waistband of current pants
                          Goal - To wear the next size down - 11/13/09
                          Goal - To wear the next size down - without a muffin top!! 11/18/09
                          Goal - To wear 'those' jeans (ya know - the ones in the back of the closet, hidden under a winter coat)
                          Day 13 - wine free/ cheat free

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                            Dr. Atkins said if it is not for you, that is fine. However, he stressed that it's not a quick fix to lose and then stop and have everything fine. And that anyone must stick to any diet in order to lose, and if you move on to another diet, have the plan ready and start it as soon as you stop following Atkins, or you will gain weight. Don't wait even a day. It's OK not to do Atkins. Just my opinion. Personally, I must be on Atkins, can't live without it, but it's not for everyone. He also stated, for example in the previous edition of DANDR, that if you crave fruit, do the the 4 day fruit diet, but you will find out why Atkins plan is more stable and how better you feel. Hope that makes sense...in other words, to each his own.

                            PS I'm not meaning to sound like I'm going against the grain, either way.
                            ~Babs
                            F, 51

                            STAC MEMBER
                            Route 66 Challenge 6/250miles
                            Feb. 2010 Water Challenge, 96 0z/day













                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Disbelief of Atkins

                              Originally posted by Capemay Eagle
                              I would be the one he is referring to, and I have read the book cover to cover and followed every step. So I am bashing Atkins. It is possible to lose weight on another diet. I did lose approx 15 pounds in a month, so the diet can work and I am happy with the results. So you all can continue to bash me, I just love success. So you all can preach the diet and how great it is, but in all honesty I really don't care. Adios..
                              You are right that I am the one who was referring to you. But I was not claiming that YOU did not read the book, only the people that were telling you that this WOE wasn't healthful. They are the ones who need to read the book. As for you, I wasn't dissing you at all on your future endeavors, just the so called "non-believers" who THINK they know what Atkins is all about.

                              Male


                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X