Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What's Your Ideal Weight?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What's Your Ideal Weight?

    Most people have a target weight in mind that they'd like to reach and maintain where
    they think they look their best. This is only natural. But too many people set goals for
    themselves that are not reasonable. When setting these goals, I can't overstress how
    important it is to be practical.
    I've had many patients come to me for weight reduction with entirely unreasonable
    expectations. Even those people who are supposedly "going by the charts" can be
    misled because those charts often don't take into account various body structures and
    individual differences.

    A woman patient will come to me. She'll be 5 feet 6 inches, with medium bone
    structure, weighing in at 215 pounds. She'll stand there and look me in the face and
    say, "I want to get down to 115 lbs," though this is totally wrong for her. Her "ideal
    weight" would probably be somewhere in the 135-145 range. She'd be in trouble at
    115. It just wouldn't be healthy.
    Unrealistic goals can also be very counterproductive. If a woman weighs 180 pounds
    and says she's going to get down to 125, that can really work against her. She may
    lose 20-25 pounds and find herself in the 160 pound range and holding for one
    reason or another. But instead of feeling proud and motivated, and thus knowing that
    she'll be able to break her holding pattern, she's got it in the back of her mind that
    she's still got 35 pounds to lose. She gets discouraged and this can really play havoc
    with her overall dedication to a sensible diet.
    Instead of setting these "ideal weight" goals, I think it's far better to put your goals on
    a weekly basis (like the 1.5-2 pound loss outlined above). Best of all, I think it's
    wisest to keep the scale locked up except for the occasional use and measure your
    progress by the way you look and feel.
    The best way to do this is to forget setting weight goals and, at the beginning of your
    diet, establish a mental image of how you want to look. It can be your own mental
    picture of a successful you or the overall look of a friend or somebody else you know.
    I've helped thousands of people lose weight over the last 20 years and, for most, this
    devotion to achieving your mental image seems to work far better and provide
    superior motivation to weighing yourself.
    Besides, the reason you're losing the weight is to get the body you want. I think it's far
    better to keep that realistic body image you're shooting for in your mind and measure
    your progress according to it. Think of the way you want to look and feel. What do you
    want to see in the mirror looking back at you? That's your goal, not some arbitrary
    number on a scale that might or might not indicate your level of fitness, health and
    attractiveness.
    So, don't pick a goal weight. You can keep a running weekly total on pounds and
    inches and measure your body fat progress with your calipers. If you have access to
    equipment that will measure total body fat, use it. Men should keep in mind that
    ideally they should maintain a body comprised of around 10 percent or less body fat.
    Women should be at or lower than 18 percent.
    Whatever you do, don't make weight your final destination. Its how you look that is
    important. Pick a realistic body look that you'd like (remember that most of us aren't
    going to make Fabio or Cindy Crawford territory) and strive for it. This is much more
    likely to motivate you and it's also a more accurate barometer of your progress. If
    you're doing things right on the Diet, it will show up in the mirror quite
    clearly. You don't need the scales or charts.(1)
    1. Di Pasquale, B. Sc.,M.D., Losing the Weight, Metabolic Diet - The Revolutionary Diet that Explodes the Myths About Carbohydrates and Fats, Metabolic Diet.com, April 2000; Chapter 5.
    Last edited by Georgiana; July 22, 2009, 10:56 PM. Reason: added quote tags
    sigpic Me, at 195 lb. September 24, 2009. It's 5:30 a.m. and can't wait to hit the coffee.

  • #2
    Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

    At 5ft 7ins tall im weighing in at 178.8(today) but my ideal weight I really want to be which is healthy for me is 150lb.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

      I am close to being 5'1 (5 f 4/5ths in) and I am currently (as last weigh in) 168.2lbs. I have a small frame and would like to be 115lbs (healthy range being 100-130).
      5'1/21/F

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

        Thank you! It's true- It's so much better to gauge success this way... Numbers can be fun but in the end it's not as important as health and a feeling of wellbeing- Going by the mental picture is an awesome way to put it !
        Used to be 120 and under... Then evened out to 140... Now headed back down from 195

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

          Encouraging article, thank you. I was particularly needing a bit of that today. I do understand, mentally, why it is important not to let the scale get me down. It's just that I am working so hard right now (weights/cardio) and ... emotionally ... I guess I was looking forward to consistent compensation in that linear fashion so few women ever see. I know that is totally unrealistic, but I go there at times, anyway.

          Originally posted by neutronnorman View Post
          ...
          A woman patient will come to me. She'll be 5 feet 6 inches, with medium bone
          structure, weighing in at 215 pounds. She'll stand there and look me in the face and
          say, "I want to get down to 115 lbs," though this is totally wrong for her. Her "ideal
          weight" would probably be somewhere in the 135-145 range. She'd be in trouble at
          115. It just wouldn't be healthy.

          ...Dr. Mauro Di Pasquale
          This part hit home and made me chuckle. I just happen to be 5' 6", medium frame and I can say "Amen" in witness to the fact I was in big trouble when I tried to maintain 115 pounds in my twenties/early thirties. Not only was it an unhealthy weight for me, but it really showed to those around me who loved me. I was in trouble because they cooked and baked and enticed me every time they saw me and, wow, did that ever put the pounds on this (still untreated at that time) hypo body in quick order! Gave new meaning to the word "trouble" for me.



          F - 5' 4.53"

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

            I have to say that whenever I read that I shouldn't weigh daily, I cringe. It's the not-weighing that contributed to me getting to where I am. I had no idea I weighed so much! I know that I'm in the minority, but I don't FEEL fat. Yes, I look it. Ask anyone. But, I can get my work done & spend time with my kids without pooping out and I feel good every day--even more so now that I'm eating healthy--but even before. Now that I have nearly lost my first 50 pounds, I FEEL skinny. My clothes are loose, I can walk places without getting out of breath, etc. If it wasn't for my trusty scale every morning, reminding me of where I need to be to be healthy, I might stay here awhile! Maybe my brain is too good at lying to me when I look in the mirror? Or maybe I just can't even imagine what healthy will look like on me. Anyway, I need my scale so that I stay true to this way of eating and catch myself gaining before it is so out of control again. I plan to weigh myself every day for the rest of my life! I know that weight fluctuates and I don't get depressed by it because I know how to fix it if things start heading in the wrong direction.

            That said, I'm not hooked on my goal weight. I just chose the number in the middle of the healthy range for me. Any weight in the range would be wonderful!
            330/216/130

            Goal 1- 280 Met July 20, 2009
            Goal 2- 250 Met Sept 28, 2009
            Goal 3- 230 Met Nov 8, 2009
            Goal 4- 199
            Goal 5- 180
            sigpicx2

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

              My ideal weight is where I finally quit losing on a carb restricted way of eating.I know how many carbs i can eat and still lose weight so the unknown is what I will be when I have dropped the last lb I can squeeze out.At 6 foot 1 and 1/2 inches I would say around 179-185.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

                it'd be nice to just be in a healthy range. for my height at 5'10 according to fitday its between 128.9 and 174.2. I'm about a medium built i suppose, but 170 has been my goal. last time i was 180 i was in a 14 jeans, so the day i fit into a 10/12 i may be 170, i may be 160, i have no idea.
                F/24/5'10"
                hw250/sw226.6/cw ?? /gw170

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

                  Thank you for the article. My weight goal is 135 because I have been there,I felt and looked my best then. I am 5'5 so that's pretty healthy for me.
                  F/5'5


                  SW-180
                  CW-160
                  GW-135




                  -20lbs
                  5 inches gone so far

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: What's Your Ideal Weight?

                    When I first started, I weighed 216 pounds. I wasn't sure how much I could lose, so I set a goal of 190. Within a few days, I had adjusted that to 181. Then, when I got closer to 181, I did a lot of research on the internet and decided 176 would be better, so I adjusted my goal for the third time. When starting off, had I set the goal at 176, I think it would have been more difficult.
                    Born 1967. 6' 1". Male.

                    Started Atkins 28th April, at 216 pounds. Met goal weight on 9th July, at 176 pounds. New goal is to become trimmer without losing weight.


                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X