I heard more about the discussion and this is what I'm hearing as regards Pam's hearing tell of the possibility that weight charts are flawed in the US.
1) People weigh more now because we exercise more, and muscle weighs more than fat
2) BMI is flawed
Based on those 2 premises, it isn't saying that it's all right to be unhealthy and overweight... it's just an assertion that based on Americans exercising more and noting that BMI can be incredibly flawed, there is more to health than a mere weight.
That's what I heard as clarity regarding the issue recently.
:joy
go to the website fluffynomore has on her post. it is the second post. The reason they say it is because we possibly have better doctors care. That first website kind of sums up what I heard.
Pam
I used to live just to eat, now I eat just to live.
Female
sw/220+cw/141/ goal/mini goal 130
height 5'1" current loss is 79 pounds 11 to go to mini goal
started atkins 10/1/05
hahah well i think that midly overwieght people would be healthier than someone who is severely malnurshised....but thats kinda like saying some one with a mild cold is healtheir than someone wiht HIV....the media always blows things out of proportion
21yrs female
5'8"
** hw-200lbs /restart-176.6 /cw-168lbs/lifetime gw 135lbs**
13lbs to go before first mini goal
28lbs to go before South Africa
33lbs to go for GOAL oh man oh man......
Comment