Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

teenagers and atkins good idea?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • teenagers and atkins good idea?

    hi all, I've a question for ya'll. my niece, aged 14, would like to try this diet. what do you think? there is nothing in the book about kids going on this type of diet. should she do it? ofcourse my brother would get her the proper vitamins and such, but i'm still a little unsure.........does anyone know?
    thanx, theresa

  • #2
    Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

    I think there is a Teens Forum here, and they should have the answers. I think it would be safe, and good for her self esteem and its better to learn good eating habits when you are young. I wish my Mom had put me on this when I was a chubby teen. Good Luck!
    What would we do without it?



    Mini-goal- 149 by June 1st. I can do it!!!

    Started this WOL on Feb. 13, 2006.

    SW 179
    CW 155
    GW 135
    5' 4"
    OWL Rung 3- Seeds and Nuts



    Frankenfoods- Low Carb Shakes, Bars, Candies.
    Sugar Alcohols= Weight loss stalls and cravings!!
    These are BAD for us!!!!

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

      Hi and welcome. Teenagers can be successful on this way of eating. Just remember that you're still growing and your body is going through lots of changes. You might want to check in with your doctor.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

        My daughter did Atkins (at 16), lost 15 lbs. Teens really need a support system to make this work.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

          If she came up with the idea totally on her own, then she'll definatly need some support. Since she is under 16 I'd have her check in with her doctor first. Otherwise yes, the diet has been shown to work for children even.
          230/154? /145

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

            Since there is nothing unhealthy about this WOE there really should be no problem. If she has a weight issue, this is a good way for her to learn how to eat healthy for life. If she really isn't too chunky then following later phases of Atkins may be best as young adolescents tend to chunk up around 14 or 15 only to go through a growth spurt during the next couple of years and become slim - that happened to me. Had I learned to eat healthfully during that time, my weight wouldn't have been an issue when I got married and started taking oral contraceptives, etc.

            Currently, I am in the OWL phase and have been raising my 2 year old daughter on this WOE for the past 5 months. Granted, I haven't put her on induction but there are many days where she pretty much just eats what I eat. Despite the lower levels of carbs, she's growing fine and remains at a healthy weight for her height. She still even has some baby fat but she isn't a butterball. Additionally, if I serve her Mac & cheese along with chicken and green beans - guess what she'll eat??? She eats her green beans first then her chicken and works on her mac & cheese. Outside of having fries every once in a while, she doesn't even like potatoes. Yes, I do let her have juice and fruits and she loves those but prefers berries over all other fruits.

            Really, I cannot see a downside to having any child try this WOE.
            27 F 5' 7"
            Before baby: HW:230/195 after 6 months on Atkins
            After baby and current restart: 210/207/120

            I'm too sexy.....for this bod; WAY too sexy for this bod

            Phase: Restarting a clean Induction as of 7/29/2007.

            Minigoals:
            To get thru my first week clean: (8/05/2007) Done! Yay! and 3lbs down :/ but at least it's a loss.
            To get thru my second week clean: (8/12/2007)
            199lbs:
            189lbs:
            179lbs:
            169lbs:
            159lbs:
            149lbs:
            139lbs:
            129lbs:
            Goal!:

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

              i think in an ideal situation the whole family would be on the 'diet' with her so she doesn't feel excluded. But once again i'd say this only if she really wants to try this and that she isn't being pressured into doing so. Because my dh and i are on atkins our four kids often end up eating what we do at meal times. But yet i still buy bread and cereals for them too. I guess its a sensitive topic for me, to this day i feel uncomfortable talking to my mom about dieting, she was disappointed in me growing up fat and always said i should lose weight.

              restarted 7/23/09 HW 338/SW 280/ CW 261.2/ GW 185 37yrs/5'11

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                Look at what Stuart acheived when he was 19.

                Second in this gallery


                Atkins didn't say 'Calories don't count',
                he said, 'Don't count calories.'
                --------------------------------------
                Male 6 ft 3in 60 years old. Married 28 years.
                Began Atkins March 04 at 260lb, reduced to 203lb by April 07 and maintained.
                Blood Pressure Mar 04 147/94 . Jun 04 121/74 . Dec 04 119/72 . Jan 06 126/71 . Dec 07 110/70
                Atkins makes exercise mandatory - I took up cycling - see last pics at 203lb.


                http://www.fitday.com/WebFit/PublicJournals.html?Owner=labarum

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                  Nobody needs refined carbohydrates .. adults or teens. Everyone can benefit by incorporating lean meats, non-starchy veggies and low-glycemic fruits into their diet.

                  Betty
                  [/IMG]

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                    Those shorts look a bit big to me, Betty!
                    Atkins didn't say 'Calories don't count',
                    he said, 'Don't count calories.'
                    --------------------------------------
                    Male 6 ft 3in 60 years old. Married 28 years.
                    Began Atkins March 04 at 260lb, reduced to 203lb by April 07 and maintained.
                    Blood Pressure Mar 04 147/94 . Jun 04 121/74 . Dec 04 119/72 . Jan 06 126/71 . Dec 07 110/70
                    Atkins makes exercise mandatory - I took up cycling - see last pics at 203lb.


                    http://www.fitday.com/WebFit/PublicJournals.html?Owner=labarum

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                      Originally posted by Labarum
                      Those shorts look a bit big to me, Betty!
                      Yeah, Brian, I know .. thanks for noticing! Can you believe these are a "small"?? I swear, I can't find decent shorts for these chicken legs of mine!

                      Betty
                      [/IMG]

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                        I agree with Betty. We are eating very healthy on Atkins. I don't see why Teens can't eat veggies, meats, salads. Also, the exercise, water and supplements won't hurt her, so I really think as long as she sees a doctor first -- there won't be a problem. The teens in the ADBB are doing great and feeling more self-confident and energetic.
                        Starting Date 3/12/04 285/165/145 - F



                        Dedication gives wings to our dreams and keeps them in flight! In One Word...COMMITTMENT.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                          the issue with Teens is they are still growing and developing so you want to make sure they don't get shortchanged in the vits and minerals or even the total amount of healthy foods they need to grow on.

                          Dr Atkins in his last TV interview discussed teens on Atkins with a parent of some overweight kids and when ask when an overweight teen could start his plan his reply was why wasn't she already on it.
                          by the book atkinseer

                          started 6/1/02 at 313
                          goalie 5/04 at 167 with under 15% body fat ADBB Presidents exercise Challenge


                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                            thanx all for your replies. my niece is 14.5 yrs old. she is grossly overwieght and her weiight problem is compounded by the fact that she is only 4 feet 7 inches tall, and this appears to be it for her. at this height, she'll never carry 10 lbs even without it being noticeable. i feel safe saying that she probably weighs at the very least, 50 lbs more than she should. my brother, (her father) and her did this diet. but my brother didn't follow the book or anything, just heard about it at work and made it up as he went along. he did well on it, but he does maintainance at a mall and walls so much each and every day. my neice has little or no exercise. i just visited him this weekend, they live in georgia to my new jersey, and i noticed my brother makes very unhealthy meals, and there is no encouragement on his part for her to do anything. when i questioned him, he told me, i told her, you show me 2 weeks of a commitment to some sort of exercise, and i'll support anything you do. i feel for my neice, i know she's about to enter hs and she has 2 major disadvantages during these so tough next 4 years with her height and weight. i wondered if my brother should maybe make only the healthiest meals, and encourage her to do more, or if his attitude is the right one. i don't see them that often, so i didn't want to speak out of turn.
                            what do you guys think? should i say more?
                            theresa

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: teenagers and atkins good idea?

                              well since he is responsible for her and her health as the parent this shouldn't even need to be said. YES you should confront him about making healthy meals and serving them. If she doesn't eat them then that is another issue. If you are able to ask him to make an appointment with her doc for her when you will be there and go with her. Can you and she be Atkins buddies on the net? and you boot camp her?
                              by the book atkinseer

                              started 6/1/02 at 313
                              goalie 5/04 at 167 with under 15% body fat ADBB Presidents exercise Challenge


                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X