Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Don't let the scale upset you

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Don't let the scale upset you

    I've said before that I weigh officially every two weeks, but because I'm a curious little bunny, I check the scale constantly - several times a day when I'm home on vacation, and a minimum of every morning when I wake up. And I never let what the scale says bother me during those interim days between official weighs - though I do celebrate like crazy when there's a drop. Here's why:

    You can't actually gain 3 lbs in a day. Not of fat. It has to be water. Any physician will tell you so.

    You can't get dehydrated on this woe if you drink a minimum of 64 oz of water a day. Therefore, any low weight is not a sign of dehydration. Bear with me, here.

    Last Friday, I was at 224. Woo hoo! That's an 11 lb. drop from my first day - unbelievable for me, because I never lose 11 lbs on induction. Celebration time!

    On Saturday, I was at 227. Was I bummed? No, because I was still counting the weight at 224. That was my "working weight" , as it was the lowest it's been since I started. The extra 3 lbs? Water. Would come off the next day, or 2 days later - whenever.

    Sunday? I was back to 225. monday? 224. Yesterday? 222. WOO HOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Today? 224 - but I still count it as 222, remember. The extra 2 is now water.

    I only count the lowest weight. I never sweat the higher ones - they are always just water and will come off in a flash.

    So why does my body do this? down, then up, then down again, then up slightly, then farther down? Probably my body retains water to compensate for a loss of fat - sort of filling in the lost areas with water until it feels like it's "safe" to let it all go.

    Here's how I envision it: 2 lbs of fat goes "whoosh". Within 24 hours, my body says "oh, hello! We've got a loss of fat here......" and fills in the missing areas with water. That water is probably CLEANSING. It's catching all of the enzymes and bits of fat cells, etc., that were left behind that I don't need anymore. It may take 48-72 hours to do the cleansing, but what do I care? It's doing the cleaning.

    And when it's done............it comes out, and I start the process again.
    Start date: 7/29/2007

    Scale: SW:235 CW:193
    GW:150

    Tape Measure: I've lost 42.5 inches as of 3/15/2008

    Mini goals:
    215 - met 9/10/07
    205 - met 10/17/07
    195 - met 2/20/08
    180

    I survived a two-month stall!

    [


  • #2
    Re: Don't let the scale upset you

    Well, I like your idea. Maybe there's truth to that! I don't think theres anything wrong with scale hopping. this time I'm waiting and only getting on every 2 wks. I think its motivating me to stay in gear and make sure that numbers gonna be lower.
    Cya, Mojo
    HW 209 restartW 190 CW 183 GW 135
    height 5'7"
    restart 10-13-08

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Don't let the scale upset you

      Great post! Thats one way of looking at it!
      30/F/5'6"
      Start Weight 245+lbs. in January 2004
      rerererererestart 6/08/2007 @ 185
      6.2 FEET of FAT GONE
      In MY JOURNAL, you can say BOOBIES!





      MySpace

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Don't let the scale upset you

        Amen!!!!
        SW226(in 2005)CW204 GW145 36F 5' 6"
        LOWEST WEIGHT 160! UGH!
        226

        Lowest Weight...UGH!160

        "You can never be to thin or have too many shoes!"
        Day 11 - Cheat FREE!
        Ran/Walk(it's HOT!) 14.5 Miles & 10 miles bike in June










        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Don't let the scale upset you

          Evermind,

          Your posts are so insightful. I'm very glad your back.
          Candy
          female/age 48 restart date 4/30/07
          mini goal 180 by 7/28/07 achieved!
          mini goal 170 by 11/1/07


          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Don't let the scale upset you

            I love that kind of logic...It does make sense! I get on the scale "unofficially" every morning (you know, after the pee) just to see how I am doing, but it doesn't count. In my mind, only the official weigh in counts...the rest, I don't let get to me. This morning my daughter was all excited because she weighed herself at the gym and weighed 8 pounds less than on my home scale...well...I had to be the bad guy and tell her that it must be wrong because my home scale gives me the same results as my doctor's scale...so 2 against 1...I'm such a meanie sometimes ...
            F44yrs young 5'7" SW172/CW152/GW140
            restart date december 08, 2009!
            1st mini-goal: 160 lbs - reached Jan 05, 2010
            2nd mini-goal: 155 lbs - reached Feb 02, 2010
            3rd mini-goal: 150 lbs
            4th mini-goal: 145 lbs
            GOAL : 140 lbs :chillpill:dancingba:dancing:

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Don't let the scale upset you

              That's exactly how I always lose weight when doing Atkins. It's like two steps forward, one step back, two steps forward, one step back. I always thought it was weird and just me until I came here and read that LOTS of people experience this. It's both great and horrible at the same time. It's hard not to get upset about gaining two pounds when you can get so excited about losing two.

              I did read an article online that talked about fat cells being temporarily plumped with water until your body decides it's safe to let them shrink. It makes a lot of sense. And let's not forget the muscle we're all building from all the exercise challenges we're doing and protein we're eating. That definitely weighs more than fat and is much more compact!

              Great post Evermind!
              Highest weight when I found Atkins in 2002: 225
              RS: 195 / CW: 173
              GL1: 179 ~ met Nov. 5, 2008
              GL2: 175 ~ met Jan 22, 2009
              GL3: 169 ~ met Jun 1, 2009
              GW: 145 (with lots of muscle!)

              Pledging Flights - Stair Climber Challenge
              442/662 flights (Cypress Hills, Saskatchewan)
              413/413 flights (Mt. Krumpet, Whoville) | 249/249 flights (Mont Brome, Quebec)
              344/344 flights (Mt. Carlton, New Brunswick) |
              152/152 flights (Nuttby Mountain, Nova Scotia)
              60/60 flights (Highest Point in PEI) | 203/203 flights (Mount McKay, Thunder Bay, Ontario)





              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                Originally posted by Evermind
                Here's how I envision it: 2 lbs of fat goes "whoosh". Within 24 hours, my body says "oh, hello! We've got a loss of fat here......" and fills in the missing areas with water. That water is probably CLEANSING. It's catching all of the enzymes and bits of fat cells, etc., that were left behind that I don't need anymore. It may take 48-72 hours to do the cleansing, but what do I care? It's doing the cleaning.

                And when it's done............it comes out, and I start the process again.
                Brilliant! I may print this out and tack it over my scale as a reminder.
                ~* BluegrassMama *~

                Post-partum re-start Mini Goals:
                145
                139
                135
                129
                125
                GOAL 120!!!


                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                  tThanks for sharing your thoughts on this...makes me all warm and fuzzy knowing I'm not alone in that thinking process

                  April 2007: 212
                  Today: 190:D :walking
                  1st Goal 189
                  Goal: 165




                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                    I love this idea. The whole thought of working from your lowest weight and forgetting all the rest is brilliant. Yesterday I was 233 and this morning I was 234. Confused as I was, here I am at this post and now I feel better.

                    Status: Rockin' OWL

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                      EVERMIND YOU'RE WONDERFUL! 2 WEEKS AGO I WAS ABOUT TO THROW IN THE TOWEL DUE TO THE UP AND DOWN ON THE SCALE AND THEN I READ THIS! I FEEL SOOOO MUCH BETTER KNOWING I'M NOT ALONE.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                        I'm bumping this up because a lot of people need this reminder!

                        Your lowest weight is your official weight. Anything higher is not a fat gain!
                        Start date: 7/29/2007

                        Scale: SW:235 CW:193
                        GW:150

                        Tape Measure: I've lost 42.5 inches as of 3/15/2008

                        Mini goals:
                        215 - met 9/10/07
                        205 - met 10/17/07
                        195 - met 2/20/08
                        180

                        I survived a two-month stall!

                        [

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                          This is such an awesome post. I missed it the first time, thanks for bumping it back up. I needed to hear it today.

                          I am day four of re-induction. Yesterday, I was two pounds down and today I was back up a little (same as start weight) BUT I know that I am in ketosis. I can feel it...


                          149.8/no weigh/ 119



                          1st goal: 139 (earlier weight)
                          what the rungs mean to me:
                          rung 1 - more veggies
                          rung 2 - dairy (some milk in coffee)
                          rung 3 - seeds, nuts (mostly sprinkled on salads)
                          rung 4 - berries, melon
                          rung 5 - wine -
                          rung 6 - beans, hummus
                          rung 7 - other fruits
                          rung 8 - carrots/ potatoes (nah, prolly not)
                          rung 9 - whole grains (fresh Dutch breads...)
                          Major Goal - 128 lbs/ healthy range
                          (on to pre-maintenance)

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                            I am totally yo yo with my weight I always go by the lowest though I never had an explanation as to why I just knew it had to be right. ( Or I was hoping) LOL but now I know!!!!!!! I am such a scale aholic hopping on several times a day as i feel like it keeps me in check. I am being brave and entered the no weigh challenge for the week starting tomorrow. I am going to have hubby hide my scale as I will never make it otherwise. I still haven't decided that weighing in a lot is bad, I really think it works as a tool for me even when I only count the lows when I see a number a bit higher it makes me take notice to things like ... salt intake water drinking ect .......... We'll see how things go with a no weigh challenge maybe it will change my way of thinking ......... hmmmmmmm time will tell!

                            Heidi
                            Heidi
                            41-Female



                            My Journal


                            My Two Youngest



                            Tyler (GS) Olivia (D) Caleb(S) Cole (GS) and Alyssa (GD)

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Don't let the scale upset you

                              You know I just read yesterday that when you lose weight rapidly your body releases all those trapped chemicals and toxins that its stored up in the fat cells. I for one want all that junk out of me so if they fill back up with water all the better--lol. They get rinsed clean!
                              Status: Rockin' OWL

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X