Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Emaciated?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Emaciated?

    Took my wife to our family doctor (we really like him, delivered both of our children, etc..) for a back problem. While she was seeing him, he looked at me with a bewildered look and said:

    Doc: Have you lost weight?
    Me: Yup.
    Doc: On purpose?
    Me: Yes, probably 40 pounds since I last saw you.

    At this point I expected "How'd you do it?" or "You look very healthy" or "Keep up the good work". Instead I got.

    "Don't lose anymore. You look emaciated."

    I wasn't sure what it meant at the time, but I knew it wasn't complimentary.

    Looked it up. Synonyms are: gaunt, haggard cadaverous, bony, and skeletal. Definitiion is extremely thin, especially from starvation, disease or cold.

    Huh? He didn't even ask what I weighed. 175 for a 5'10" male is technically still overweight. I am at 15.4% body fat. My goal is around 160. Still have a roll around the belly to get rid of so I can actually see my abs some day.

    Do I look gaunt? I've lost 15 pounds since the picture, but I don't see 15 pounds worth of change in the mirror.

    Not being conceited here, but I think for the first time in my adult life, that I look pretty good.

    Sometimes I think people are so used to seeing everyone overweight or obese that anyone at a "healthy" weight appears to be "too thin" or in some way sick.

    Sorry for the rant. I have worked real hard to become healthy, a marathoner, and the only comment I get from my doctor is that I look sick.

    How deflating (no pun intended).

    Rich
    HW247 / RSW247 / CW238 / GW174

    Male

  • #2
    Re: Emaciated?

    Well, you've lost more since your pic, but you don't look emaciated in that pic at all! I'd say you look muscular and athletic, but not emaciated!!!

    Maybe the doc is jealous of your success!
    Freckles, 26F
    297/241/150 5'3" Sz 26/20/8




    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Emaciated?

      You look good to me. In your picture it doesn't look like you need to lose anymore, but I wouldn't say you are scrawny or emaciated. A while back some people were saying that Betty (ttdriver) was too skinny too. I think that runners are naturally more lean looking than other people and as you say, the majority of the population is overweight these days so anyone who's not looks underweight. I think you look great!
      Female, 46yrs, 5'3"

      Restarted Atkins 09/19/05
      Re-restarted Atkins 03/12/07

      SW198.5/CW215/GW150







      Slug Free 6WEC#21 & 22 & 23

      "Superhuman willpower is not required to do Atkins, only the wisdom to put yourself into a position where you won't need it."

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Emaciated?

        Originally posted by BigRunner


        Sometimes I think people are so used to seeing everyone overweight or obese that anyone at a "healthy" weight appears to be "too thin" or in some way sick.
        I think you are pretty much right on the money with that statement. I wouldn't let what he said bother me, go by how you feel. But that is just my opinion.
        Started March 27,2006 29 Lb's & 3 sizes GONE!
        Female 5'10"
        HW 280 Size Maternity 2XL
        SW 260 Size 24 / CW 231Size 18 / GW 160 Size 9








        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Emaciated?

          By any chance does the good doctor need to lose a few? People are so insecure, they can't help it. You look awesome- keep up the good work!
          5'9" 38/f

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Emaciated?

            I usually get responses like that from people who are overweight to begin with or if they sense some competition. Focus on your goal and stick to it. You will probably get an equal number of good and negative responses. Be happy with yourself
            Start Date 5/9/06
            Height 5' 2'
            Age 25

            HW: 131
            CW: 125
            GW1: 118
            GW2: 110

            Nothing tastes as good as thin feels

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Emaciated?

              You look great to me. Not emaciated at all. I think maybe the doc was just taken by surprise by your loss and used to seeing you more...erm... upholstered!
              Before and after:






              PLEDGING FLIGHTS
              Completed: 1st set of buildings and mountains (Everest,M.Blanc & Kilimanjaro, twice); Tower Masts & Chimneys; More virtual buildings; Challenger's Choice x 2 (volcanos and mountains on Mars). Currently climbing: Mount Snowdon again: 416/475

              Start 10 Jan 2005. Maintenance since Aug. 2005.
              F/56yrs/5'.4"
              SW:77.7 LW:56.5 CW:60.1 (kilos)

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Emaciated?

                I think we addressed this in the OWL forum that your % body fat is within normal limits for a man. Also weight (poundage) is moot if you are actively building muscle mass. 1 pound of muscle is the same weight as 1 pound of fat.

                As for how we perceive ourselves....yes many people (me included) look in the mirror and see the same fat person we were when we began our weight loss journey. I'm half the person I was when I began but I still see myself as that larger person. So we need to work on getting our heads straight while we are losing weight.
                ~Megs~
                242/141/160 (130)
                dress size 26/10/8
                5'4", Female, May 2, 2003
                My blog:
                http://mformiscellaneous.blogspot.com/

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Emaciated?

                  LOL! Upholstered! I LOVE IT! HA-HA-HA!
                  5'9" 38/f

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Emaciated?

                    Rich, from your photo, clearly yours is a physique most men aspire to. Keep that in mind in the future when hit with backhanded compliments - or in this case, outright insults.
                    Sheila, Founder of SugarFreeSheila.com
                    5'3", medium-framed & muscular, & maintaining since 2001

                    What's allowed on Induction

                    My new YouTube Before/After slideshow

                    Then: 140+, size 10-12
                    Late '98, on top of the Empire State Building



                    Now: 109, size 0
                    January 2010 - Malta

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Emaciated?

                      HAH! I'll just bet your doc is heavier than you, and/or he's just kidding you because he's jealous!
                      ~Susan
                      49/f 5'7" Start 2-27-06 SW222/11-18-09 @ 160-ish/G135-150ish??

                      Doin Miles, Flights, & Kid Ketchin'...
                      2 Ab Chal's; 6WEC#27 slug-Free; & more; 50# LOST in'06-
                      but regained ~20# in '07 in less than 3 weeks! And again early '08 ...Was in HEAVEN -got to 150, for awhile, then got too busy, and gave in too much... and... OK holding pattern "keep it together..."

                      .................OMG how did I fail AGAIN
                      (((on temporary break)))
                      Sigh ... I'll be back... life isn't always fair 10-07-09

                      "Goal: First you have to dream of it. Then you have to do it." Author unknown

                      sheesh

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Emaciated?

                        I agree. You look great in your photo and if you feel good, then don't let anyone take your dream away. I've had a few doctors give me negative comments about my weight loss, but my family doctor is thrilled and behind me.
                        Starting Date 3/12/04 285/165/145 - F



                        Dedication gives wings to our dreams and keeps them in flight! In One Word...COMMITTMENT.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Emaciated?

                          I think you look great! Huge accomplishment you should be proud. Next time you see him ask him to take your blood pressure then SCREAM in his stethascope


                          Tommy
                          Male
                          Where I work: The Longfin

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Emaciated?

                            Originally posted by Jacksuncle
                            I think you look great! Huge accomplishment you should be proud. Next time you see him ask him to take your blood pressure then SCREAM in his stethascope
                            PERFECT!!! I could not have said it better myself

                            I was told I looked "sick" when I hit my goal... by a very overweight nurse I work with ...who can not reach to pick anything up she uses a claw...nothing wrong with that ..and I sure would never have said she looks sick..but to be honest..she does!!! she looks really sick younger than I am and unable to bend ot pick stuff up ...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Emaciated?

                              I bet that claw makes da bomb back scratcher. I have never heard of that and actually it is making me sad thinking of it and therefore I wont clown it.


                              Tommy
                              Male
                              Where I work: The Longfin

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X