I used the menu on page 133. I assumed 3 oz of butter for cooking, and estimated veggie servings. I didn't add any dressings, that would have brought the fat up from 61 percent. I made the cream 2 oz.
Here is the nutrient breakdown for this day from Sparkpeople.
NUTRIENTS: GOAL / TODAY
Calories: 1250 - 1600 /1,731
Fat: 28 - 62 /120
Carbohydrates: 141 - 260 /35
Protein: 31 - 140/ 132
Calcium, Ca: 100 - 150 /56
Fiber, total dietary: 25 - 35 /14
Iron, Fe: 100 - 150 /83
Magnesium, Mg: 100 - 125 /60
Selenium, Se: 100 - 200/ 290
Vitamin E: 100 - 200/ 32
Vitamin D: 100 - 150 /30
Vitamin C: 100 - 500 /146
Vitamin B-12: 100 - 200 / 253
Vitamin A, IU: 100 - 110/ 466
Riboflavin: 100 - 200 / 106
As you can see, nutient wise Atkins is quite adequate in some things, even vitamin C, while deficient in others for this day, like E and D. I thought of checking this while thinking about the post about the heavy 16 year old. Based on this, if my teen were thinking of doing Atkins I would be comfortable with this menu PLUS some yogurt and milk for D and calcium. Some nuts too. But I would not feel there was any nutritional risk at all, this is so much better than the average teen menu would play out! The average teen is going to have a higher metabolism, so a decent CCLL, so would not need to be as strict as an adult in order to lose.
Anyway, thought it would be interesting!
Here is the nutrient breakdown for this day from Sparkpeople.
NUTRIENTS: GOAL / TODAY
Calories: 1250 - 1600 /1,731
Fat: 28 - 62 /120
Carbohydrates: 141 - 260 /35
Protein: 31 - 140/ 132
Calcium, Ca: 100 - 150 /56
Fiber, total dietary: 25 - 35 /14
Iron, Fe: 100 - 150 /83
Magnesium, Mg: 100 - 125 /60
Selenium, Se: 100 - 200/ 290
Vitamin E: 100 - 200/ 32
Vitamin D: 100 - 150 /30
Vitamin C: 100 - 500 /146
Vitamin B-12: 100 - 200 / 253
Vitamin A, IU: 100 - 110/ 466
Riboflavin: 100 - 200 / 106
As you can see, nutient wise Atkins is quite adequate in some things, even vitamin C, while deficient in others for this day, like E and D. I thought of checking this while thinking about the post about the heavy 16 year old. Based on this, if my teen were thinking of doing Atkins I would be comfortable with this menu PLUS some yogurt and milk for D and calcium. Some nuts too. But I would not feel there was any nutritional risk at all, this is so much better than the average teen menu would play out! The average teen is going to have a higher metabolism, so a decent CCLL, so would not need to be as strict as an adult in order to lose.
Anyway, thought it would be interesting!

Comment